|Noah Webster: Anti-Jacobinist|
I expected a solid panel, but I did not anticipate learning so much.
Jonathan Den Hartog of Northwestern College (St. Paul) began the festivities with a paper on religion, Anti-Jacobinism, and print culture. (For those unfamiliar, Anti-Jacobinists were 1790s intellectuals who opposed the political ideas associated with the French Revolution). From a religious perspective, Anti-Jacobins opposed French irreligion, Paine's Age of Reason, and the dangers of the Illuminati. Den Hartog focused on four American Anti-Jacobin writers: grammarian Noah Webster, clergyman Timothy Dwight, printer William Cobbett, and novelist Sally Sayward Wood.
Lily Santoro of Southeast Missouri State presented a paper on the ways in which American Protestants used British texts across the Atlantic "border" to shape a distinctive discussion of science and religion in the early republic. She focused on intellectuals such as Yale professor Benjamin Silliman and Baptist minister Thomas Staughton who used the study of the natural sciences to support their republican and Christian faith.
Ashley Moreshead of the University of Delaware (both Ashley and Lily are/were Christine Heyrman students) talked about British contributions to American missionary periodicals. Missionary magazines created a sort of imagined community of Protestants that transcended national boundaries. Her paper reminded me of the work by Susan O'Brien, Frank Lambert, and others who have written similar things about the First Great Awakening.
(I hope these descriptions do some justice to the three papers).
I should also add that this panel was a model for how to present complicated ideas in a compelling, passionate way. There were no bells and whistles (Powerpoints, handouts, etc...), but all three papers were presented in a way that was very accessible to the non-specialists in the room. I don't think I have ever heard names and phrases such as "William Paley," "Edmund Burke," "natural religion," and "heathen millions" uttered in such an enthusiastic way.
In his comments, Kyle Roberts asked Den Hartog to think harder about how (and if) less popular Anti-Jacobin works were disseminated. He wondered whether Santoro's intellectuals and science writers were distinctly "American" in nature. And he asked Moreshead to examine how magazine editors repurposed European content to suit their needs.
Den Hartog, Santoro, and Moreshead are doing some great work. I look forward to reading their forthcoming works. Happy to be a pinch-hitter. (I have always been a big fan of Manny Mota and Rusty Staub).